Georgia Peanut Butter Pie - Recipe name: Georgia Peanut Butter Pie Recipe category: Desserts What are your thoughts about this interesting dish? Recipe details: 1 Unbaked 9-inch pie shell 3/4 c Sugar 1/2 c Milk 1/2 c Your opinion: We will love to know how this recipe worked for you... please share your thoughts. Culture, Family, Travel & Consumer Reviews.