For a good horror experience, I have to recommend Outlast.
Unlike many horror games, you have no weapon, your only advantage is most of the things hunting you can't see in the dark, but you have a video camera with night vision. But the batteries don't last long.
I would also recommend the Resident Evil series. They have really good jump scares and more action than you can shake a stick at. I found the ones I played fun.
Since I don't found any description from the OP I assume any game recommendation are fine
So I guess I try to recommend some niche game like dominons series which next year gonna have new sequel dominions 6, to simplify its like totalwar warhammer but in 2d and you don't control the flow of the battle.