Just added this article: It is called "Role-play" not "Dice play" to the Text Role-playing Game Blog. Basically, I cover nerd Players' obsession with dice and rules to the detriment of role-play and the exclusion of others. Of course we know the end solution already.
While I enjoy the dice I also look into the role play portion of the game too. Yeah it is easy to let the dice do everything but having a good role play of my character does this because of this is what can add a lot of depth to a role playing game.
I feel that it is not too much to ask people to know the basic rules. Any game of any sort has rules that the players need to know. Patience should be exercised with new players but they should make an effort to learn the rules. The Dungeon Master does most of the work. It isn't too much to ask of a player to do their small part.
Edited: Kyrroeth on 14th Nov, 2018 - 3:19pm
The taverns are definitely a good example of this. You can just run with the outcome of a challenge or use the time to roleplay as though you are really there in a place full of drunks and wenches.
If you're relying on dice then you probably don't know how to role-play so a board game might be better suited for you.
A certain amount of fun does come from rolling the dice but its true that a ROLE playing game should not be about ROLL playing as much as ROLE playing your character.
Dice should be for decision making and not making the decision. At least that's how I see it. Role-playing is how you get enjoyment from the game.
We break from Roleplaying vs Dice Playing to share infobreak from the past:
Today is: 22nd April (GMT), in history on the 22nd of April, 1954 AD the following birth happened:
Joseph Bottoms: Santa Barbara, California -- Actor (Surfacing, Blind Date)